The Iranian market is unintentionally experiencing a new wave of discounts; a post‑connectivity sales rush. Analyses by Taha Site using data extracted from the LiveWeb system and Datom Academy show that activity in "Bale" channels and groups and other domestic platforms has sharply declined, with users returning to their previous spaces on Telegram, Instagram and WhatsApp.
Previously, some believed that the 68% of users who did not return to Instagram within a week after the partial internet reopening did so because their needs were met on domestic platforms. Data on the decreasing presence and activity of users in these local messengers indicate that these platforms were not sufficiently responsive, and the large return to Instagram likely stems from access issues and the difficulty of connecting to VPNs.
Peak of the Discount Season Immediately After Partial Internet Reconnection
Although every country has seasonal or New‑Year night discounts, analysis of collective user behavior across Instagram, Telegram, X (Twitter), Eitaa, Bale and Rubika shows that in recent weeks, even outside the usual discount‑campaign period, the hashtag "discount" has become increasingly used on all platforms, growing 120% over the past week.
This indicates that online businesses, which lost New‑Year night sales due to the internet outage, are now trying to attract customers with discounts to compensate for the major economic shock they suffered.
Domestic Platforms in the Shadow of Political Content; Economic Businesses on the Margins of Hashtags
Contrary to the claims of domestic‑messenger advocates and global‑platform critics, native channels have not hosted economic or business‑related hashtags during the outage; no economic hashtags were observed among the most frequent tags on native platforms.
📊Reverse Migration from Native to Global Platforms: The Fall of Bale
Studying businesses on native platforms requires broader research. Yet how did the general public behave in channels and groups after the partial reconnection? The findings show that with the incomplete return of the internet, people began migrating from native channels. The data narrate the situation as follows:
27% of groups on "Bale" have been closed and activity has dropped by 81%.
A 10.5% decline in content production across all messenger groups: overall content in the four native messengers (Bale, Eitaa, Rubika, and Soroush Plus) fell 10.5% from late April to early June after the partial reconnection.
With internet back, migration from Bale intensified: 27% of groups were shut down and activity fell 81%. Activity also declined in 32% of iGap groups, while groups on Eitaa and Rubika continued to grow.
📊Comparison of Group Performance on Native Platforms (June vs. April)
Based on the figures, the average activity per group is 24% lower than before.
📊Comparison of Channel Performance During Outage and Partial Reconnection (first 7 days post‑outage in June vs. 5‑12 April)
Activity in all native‑platform channels decreased, with the biggest drops observed on Bale and Soroush Plus.
Users kept channels created during the outage for possible future disruptions.
Content production on Bale fell 55%, while the number of channels declined only slightly, indicating that users preserved the infrastructure they built during the outage for future use.
Overall, each native channel produces 42% less content on average compared to the outage period, and the number of channels is about 13% lower.
📊What Did "Bale" Lose with Internet Reconnection?
1. Data show that international‑internet restrictions in April triggered a staggering 503% surge in Bale group content production (first to seventh of March vs. fifth to twelfth of April), proving that during provider outages users temporarily turned to this platform for team, academic and daily communications.
2. June and factory‑reset: Comparing a week in June (5‑12) with a week in March (1‑7) shows that Bale could not retain the influx of users from April; once routing normalized in June, the number of active groups returned to the March level, meaning groups created in April were largely abandoned.
3. A 20% rise in channel count: The only relatively positive point for Bale in this three‑month span is the number of channels. Although channel content sharply fell in June, the number of active channels was 20% higher than in March, suggesting businesses or media that opened channels in April kept them alive with a very modest activity slope, perhaps as a backup.
Comments