Windows 11 turned five years old; five years that saw a mix of a pleasing interface, annoying decisions, and Microsoft's late efforts to regain trust.
Can you believe it has been exactly five years since Microsoft announced Windows 11? It was June 24, 2021, when this operating system was officially introduced at a news event; although, following the usual trend in the tech world, images and files had leaked a few days prior.
Microsoft promised that day that Windows 11 would be available as a free update for Windows 10 users; however, contrary to expectations, users did not immediately or eagerly migrate to the new version; a situation partly attributed to Microsoft's unnecessary strictness in setting the required minimum hardware specifications.
Audio Summary
Audio summary, created with artificial intelligence
It took nearly four years for Windows 11 to finally surpass its predecessor. According to Statcounter data, Windows 11 only managed to claim Windows 10's position as Microsoft's most widely used desktop operating system in July 2025, and today holds over 70 percent of the desktop Windows market, even as Windows 10's official support ended last October and the window for legacy version support shrinks every day.
Now we can look back and see in what ways Microsoft's operating system has improved over these five years, which choices were missed, and why Microsoft is now reconsidering many of its Day 1 decisions? Why hasn't the user relationship with Windows 11 ever been as simple as a free upgrade?
You turn on your computer, and Windows 11 boots up with its same calm image, orderly icons, and centered taskbar. You want to open a program, click Start, and type its name; but sometimes, before reaching the program, a store suggestion or a web result appears in front of you. You right-click on a file; but you cannot find the option you used to see in that menu for years. Yes, you have to click "Show more options" to find the desired option hidden behind it!
These few minutes of ordinary work largely narrate the five-year story of Windows 11. Microsoft’s operating system has become more beautiful, acquired more features, and is now present on most Windows computers; nevertheless, you still have to pass through a path that Microsoft itself places in front of you to perform some simple tasks.
The Windows that was supposed to offer a sense of calm
In October 2021, when Microsoft publicly released Windows 11, the world was just emerging from the heavy months of the pandemic, and computers had simultaneously become workplaces, classrooms, cinemas, and windows for connecting with others for many of us.
Panos Panay, then the Head of Windows, stated during the new operating system’s announcement that computers have become personal and emotional devices, not just practical tools. Microsoft also wanted to create an environment that brings the feeling of home to life; a familiar, calm, and orderly place that does not disturb the user.
Microsoft wanted Windows 11 to have a sense of home; a calm, quiet, and undisturbed place
Windows 11’s visual design evoked this same vibe. The Start menu was centered on the screen, windows had rounded corners, and the new sounds and animations felt smoother. Snap Layouts allowed multiple apps to be arranged side by side quickly, and separate desktops helped separate work from personal life.
Looking beyond Windows’s appearance, Teams Chat was integrated directly into the taskbar, widgets displayed personal information in one place, the Microsoft Store had been rebuilt from scratch, and Android apps could run on the computer. Auto HDR and DirectStorage also signaled improved gaming experiences.
The version we installed in October 2021 fulfilled some of Microsoft's promises. Snap Layouts were genuinely useful, and the new design offered a clearer identity compared to Windows 10. The issues began when Microsoft abandoned familiar behaviors to simplify Windows’s appearance, sacrificing user choice for simplicity.
Sacrificing Old User Habits for Visual Simplicity
Long-time Windows users quickly realized the new look came with a price. In the early months of Windows 11's release, the taskbar could not be moved to the side of the screen, and the option to resize it had been removed from settings. Even familiar features, such as dragging a file onto a taskbar app icon, no longer worked.
The Start menu had a sparser appearance, but half of its space was dedicated to Recommended. To see all apps, you had to proceed to the next stage, whereas Windows had reserved a fixed space for files and user-selected recommendations. Even right-clicking the taskbar showed almost only the Settings option.
Removing familiar features from the taskbar was the first blow to the experience for long-time users.
At first glance, the new design settings delight users; however, the Control Panel and windows from previous generations remained in various parts of the system. It only took a few minutes navigating through the settings to reach a 2021-era design that felt like it was left behind in the previous decade.
Microsoft quickly reintroduced some features to Windows 11. The 22H2 update restored drag-and-drop of files onto the taskbar, added more folders and layouts to Start, and finally gave File Explorer tabs. Each change improved the user experience; however, everyone asked why they had to wait a year for a feature that Windows 10 had provided from the start.
The path of Windows 11 has looked a bit strange since its first update. Microsoft introduced new features while simultaneously restoring things it had previously removed. During the first two years, most of the operating system's progress consisted of reclaiming lost ground.
Over the past five years, 6 points in the list of user complaints were repeated most often.
1. The High Hardware Wall and Confusion at the First Step
Many users did not even reach the installation stage to experience the start and taskbar changes. A computer that ran Windows 10 smoothly might be excluded from the upgrade list simply because its processor was not on the approved list or it lacked TPM 2.0. Microsoft effectively set the compatibility boundary around Intel 8th generation processors and AMD Zen 2 architecture.
The requirement for a newer processor and a TPM 2.0 chip left many upgrade-ready computers behind.
However, Microsoft's strictness stemmed from Windows' security logic. TPM stores encryption keys in a secure hardware environment, and Secure Boot prevents tampering with the boot process. The company also claimed that devices meeting the new requirements had better stability.
The issue may have been that Microsoft did not clearly explain its decision to users from the start. The PC Health Check tool initially just told many users that their computers were not suitable for Windows 11 without specifying which component or setting prevented the upgrade. User confusion grew so much that Microsoft acknowledged the ambiguity days later and published more details about the hardware criteria.
2. Mandatory Microsoft Account
Users with a healthy computer system faced three choices: stay on Windows 10, buy a new system, or install Windows 11 using methods outside official support. The previous computer's hardware might have been fine, but Microsoft assigned it a new end-of-life date.
Microsoft established a new useful life for hardware
Once we reached the hardware installation stage. From the very beginning, installing the Home edition required the internet and a Microsoft account, and the Pro edition also demanded an online account from update 22H2 onwards. Users simply wanted to log into their own computers, but Windows insisted that they first join the Microsoft ecosystem!
An online account made syncing settings, file recovery, and connecting OneDrive easier; however, there was a long way between suggesting a feature and imposing it. Users repeatedly found workarounds to create a local account, and Microsoft gradually closed off those same avenues. Some users also asked who makes the final decision regarding their computer: themselves or the operating system vendor?
3. An Operating System That Became a Browser
Microsoft resorted to WebView2 to build a large part of the Windows 11 interface and its own apps; a Chromium-based engine, the same core as Edge and Chrome browsers. Each time an app uses WebView2, a small browser-like component runs in the background.
Reliance on the WebView2 engine increased RAM consumption in simple applications
Widgets, parts of the search function, and settings pages were built on this same engine, and the Start menu was also created with React; however, the cost of this choice showed in its memory consumption.
The Windows Weather app consumed approximately 1.2 GB of RAM in idle mode, roughly five times that of the native Mac version. Teams, with a fresh account and not even a single conversation, took up nearly 963 MB. WhatsApp, after switching from its native app to WebView2, also saw its memory usage spike to 2 GB.
8 GB computers were the first casualties; systems that, on paper, met the minimum specifications for Windows 11, but in practice were barely keeping up.
4. The Advertising Vitrine
From the very first setup page, users were faced with Microsoft 365, OneDrive, and Copilot recommendations. Next came the Start menu, where the Recommended section gradually turned into a storefront for suggested apps, while Edge and Bing persistently placed themselves in the user's view. Users could disable some suggestions, but they had to navigate through the settings to find the option.
5. The AI Invasion
As the artificial intelligence market heated up, traces of Copilot gradually appeared in every corner of Windows, from Notepad and Paint to the screenshot tool and even the Start menu. The Recall feature, designed for Copilot+ PCs, allowed users to search their previous activities by taking screenshots of the display, triggering waves of privacy concerns that forced the company to delay its release several times.
6. Untimely Updates
Unwanted restarts, bugs that surfaced with every update, and drivers installed during gameplay frustrated many users. Critics called Windows 11 an operating system that required constant user attention.
2026: The Year Microsoft Shortchanged
In the spring of 2026, Apple with the MacBook Neo once again turned attention back to the Mac, and Linux, thanks to Steam Deck and advancements in game emulation tools, gained a share of over 5% among the operating systems of participating users for the first time in the March Steam survey; a small rate compared to Windows' over 90% share, but a notable sign that dissatisfied users now had more serious options for migration.
The March 2026 note by the Windows Manager marked the beginning of the return of removed features and a surrender to user demands.
On March 20, Pauvan Daowri, head of the Windows division, in a formal note referred to a series of changes that seemed to directly respond to users' complaints over the past five years.
Some of the features that Windows 11 had initially abandoned were set to return; the taskbar regained its moveable capability, and it could even be placed vertically along the screen. The presence of Copilot also became less prominent; its icon in Notepad was replaced by a simple pen titled Writing tools, and the Copilot button on the taskbar was no longer enabled by default.
The Start menu migrated from React to WinUI, Windows' native and lighter framework, and ads in the Recommended section decreased, while users could turn it off. Updates also became more flexible, allowing users to defer them for a period.
Critics noted two more areas of concern in Dave Lowry's note: the mandatory Microsoft account and the promotional content that the company had added to the Start menu. Nevertheless, after years of limiting user choices, the company appears to be changing direction.
Climbing the Hardest Peak
On April 26, 2026, Windows Central revealed the existence of an internal Microsoft program codenamed Windows K2; a long-term project that is not a new version of Windows or a precursor to Windows 12, but aims to change the very way Windows is built. This program began in the second half of 2025 and pursues three main goals: efficiency, build quality, and stability.
Peak K2, as the second-highest mountain in the world, is known for its extremely difficult ascents, and Microsoft apparently views improving the operating system used by millions of people daily as a challenge as difficult as conquering this peak.
Leaked details about K2 reveal the depth of Microsoft's ambition. The company wants File Explorer to approach the speed of File Pilot, a lightweight, independent developer file manager, and claims that Windows gaming performance will be comparable to SteamOS. Updates that require a restart will be limited to once a month, and the installation of graphics and audio drivers will be moved to outside of gaming sessions.
The K2 project is Microsoft's fundamental effort to rebuild the infrastructure, stability, and speed of Windows.
In late July, Dovlevi took the next important step, declaring that optimizing Windows for 8-gigabyte budget devices was a priority for the engineering team. To achieve this goal, Microsoft plans to redesign its memory management approach and gradually transition parts of the user interface built with WebView2 to WinUI.
Real Achievements; Features That Finally Matured
The five-year track record of Windows 11 is not defined solely by failures and challenges. Along this path, attractive features also reached maturity. For instance, the Snap Layouts feature gained significantly more usability with better support for large displays, touchscreens, and multi-monitor systems, and File Explorer was finally equipped with the popular tabs feature.
The old, simple Notepad software also received features such as tabs, automatic saving, and restoration of previous windows. Even nostalgic applications like Paint and Snipping Tool were actively redeveloped and transformed into modern tools.
Smart window arrangement and File Explorer tabs were among the most successful user interface changes in these five years.
Update 24H2 also breathed new life into the operating system, bringing key features such as the new Energy Saver mode, support for Wi-Fi 7, the addition of the Linux Sudo command, and the ability to use HDR wallpapers in Windows.
On the other hand, the Prism emulator largely improved the issue of quality degradation when running legacy x86 and x64 software on computers based on ARM processors, and the Phone Link application managed to minimize the persistent gap between smartphones and personal computers.
In terms of security as well, with the rising day-to-day cyber threats, the early hardware security requirements of Windows 11 now appear significantly more logical and defensible than before. All these improvements, alongside another major event—the end of free support for Windows 10 in October 2025—acted as a catalyst, accelerating users' migration to the new version of Windows.
Version 26H2; A return to the original home after 5 years
On September 29, one week before the fifth-anniversary birth, Microsoft released version 26H2. This year's annual update arrived quietly and without a fuss, unlike in the past, and Microsoft itself described it as an "predictable and hassle-free" update.
26H2 is offered as a small, active package and does not have a large download size; it installs with one restart and extends the support for Home and Pro versions until October 2028.
The 26H2 update upgrades the operating system hassle-free with a simple restart
On the other hand, this version brings changes that users have been waiting for for years, such as the redesigned Start menu, a taskbar that can be moved to any edge of the screen, a faster-searching File Explorer, and Point-in-time restore functionality which restores the entire system to its state a few hours or days ago. After five years, Windows 11 once again gives back things it took on the first day.
Of course, the hardware requirements have remained as strict as before, and you still need a Microsoft account to install. Scott Hanselman, Microsoft Vice President, says his team is working on removing this requirement, and news this week indicates a serious review of the issue; however, we have not yet heard any official announcement in this regard.
Five years at a glance
Release of version 26H2 with a new start and movable taskbar
Announcement of RAM optimization for 8-gigabyte computers
Official promise to fix Windows 11 and step back from Copilot
End of Windows 10 support and removal of local account creation methods
Formation of the internal K2 plan
Windows 11 surpassing Windows 10 in total installation share
End of the Android subsystem
General release of Windows 11
Unveiling of Windows 11
Windows 10 is still breathing
According to September 2026 statistics, Windows 11 holds about 71 percent of the Windows version share, with one billion users. Still, 27 percent of users are using Windows 10, although official Windows 10 support ended in October 2025, and its extended security update program will continue until October 2027.
According to Windows Latest, some Windows 10 users are probably not willing to migrate even after 2027; from their perspective, Windows 10 still works well enough that they see no reason to abandon it.
Windows 11 arrived five years ago with bold claims, and now, on its fifth anniversary, Microsoft is more than ever focused on fixing the very issues users have complained about for years. The taskbar is regaining some of its old freedoms, Copilot is stepping back from certain unnecessary corners, and engineers have even gone as far as redesigning various system components to reduce RAM consumption.
Over five years, Windows 11 has become more beautiful, complete, and inclusive; yet it is only now getting close to what it originally promised: an environment that does not interfere with users while they perform daily tasks. Perhaps the quality of an operating system is not determined by the big features announced once a year; sometimes it all comes down to our everyday clicks.
Now it is your turn. How have the five years with Windows 11 been? Are you satisfied and working with it every day, have you remained loyal to Windows 10, or have you turned your path toward Mac and Linux? Share your experience with us.
Comments